Back to Journal

Keep the answer attached to the question

A memorable quotation is easy to collect. Preserving what the person meant takes a little more care.

A note reading “24:10 — it was a disaster” looks like a promising quotation. It does not tell you whether the speaker means the apprenticeship, the first commission or the lunch served on the day they arrived.

The missing question matters. So do the sentences that follow, especially if the next one is “At least, that was how it felt for the first hour.”

Interview material becomes useful when you can move from a promising line back to the exchange that produced it. Organisation should protect that route, rather than simply produce a tidy list of quotations.

Keep three kinds of material distinct

The recording, when one exists, is a source. A transcript is a written representation of it, with whatever uncertainties or omissions the transcription process introduced. Your working notes are your interpretation: themes, questions, possible quotations and ideas for the piece.

Give them distinguishable names and a shared home. For an interview with a furniture maker, the folder might contain the dated recording, a transcript and a document called Interview working notes.md. You do not need an elaborate taxonomy; you need to avoid confusing an edited passage with the words as recorded.

At the top of the working notes, record the interview date, the person’s name and role as confirmed, the source filename, and any agreed limits on use that you need to honour. These details are dull until they are missing.

Names that describe a file’s purpose help here. Interview final.md leaves too much unexplained. Is it a final transcript, a selection of extracts or the finished article?

Mark what you know and what you think

A compact working note might distinguish three things:

24:10 — First commission
Quote candidate: "It was a disaster."
Context: describing the first attempt, not the finished piece.
Check: exact wording and whether "first" means first paid job.

This example does not ask the note to be the whole transcript. It preserves a location, a possible use and a reason to return to the source.

Keep paraphrases visibly different from quotations. If you wrote “learned more by making mistakes than by watching”, that may be a fair summary, but it should not acquire quotation marks simply because it reads well in the draft. Uncertain words also need a visible marker rather than a confident guess.

These distinctions make checking claims against their evidence possible later. They also help you notice when an attractive quotation proves less than the surrounding sentence suggests.

Reorganise your notes, not the past

After the interview, your working notes can gather themes: learning, materials, pricing, teaching. The original conversation will probably move among them. Theme-based notes help you write; timestamps or other source locations let you reconstruct the exchange.

Do not polish away a contradiction too soon. If the furniture maker describes an early mentor as both demanding and generous, those accounts may belong together. A neat category should not force the person to become simpler than the interview.

Before using a quotation, return to its surrounding exchange and check the wording, speaker and context. Read the draft beside the transcript if that helps, then consult the recording where necessary. Keep follow-up questions in a short, separate list so unresolved details do not disappear into a page of interesting material.

When another person needs to review the piece, give them enough source context to assess the passage at issue. A line selected for its force is often the line that most needs its surrounding sentences.

A little more room to think.

A free, local Markdown hub for Mac.

Mac app details